Want to learn more?
Get in touch with a friendly member of our team today
Benchmarking board performance: 500 board reviews later
Unlock evidence-based insights into board performanceIn the study by recruiting experts Hays in conjunction with diversity and employee survey specialists, Insync, 1029 hiring managers were asked to review a CV then answer a series of questions about the candidate’s attributes, skills and probability they would be interviewed. 515 reviewed the CV of ‘Susan’ and 514 reviewed an identical CV but for one notable change – the name was altered to ‘Simon’.
The study found:
More recruitment experience means more bias
The bigger the business the bigger the bias
We prefer candidates just like us – but still hire more men
Public and not-for-profit bias towards women
Organisations are still not serious (enough) about gender diversity
“At Hays, we’ve seen countless cases of hiring managers who are presented with a gender diverse shortlist but select more men than women for interview,” says Nick Deligiannis, Managing Director of Hays in Australia & New Zealand.
“Few would admit to bias but our survey results show it does exist – particularly in Australia’s largest businesses.
“It is also more likely in those who hire most frequently. This is an interesting finding since unconscious bias is more likely to impact decisions that are made quickly. Such managers would say they rely on their experience but possibly their decisions are less deliberate and therefore when an unconscious bias exists it affects their hiring decisions. In comparison, people who do not have as much hiring experience are more considered in their decisions.
“We also found that there is bias towards women in the public and not-for-profit sector and men in the private sector. This reinforces stereotypes of women being better at ‘taking care’ and men at ‘doing business’ and ‘being decisive’.
“Having unconscious beliefs isn’t the problem”, says Nicholas Barnett, CEO at Insync. “All of us have them to some extent. Not knowing we have them, not acknowledging them and not seeking to challenge them is a problem. Research actually shows that people who say they don’t have unconscious beliefs make more biased decisions than those who acknowledge their unconscious beliefs.”
Nick Deligiannis says: “This study also shows that more needs to be done to educate hiring managers around gender diversity policies and to get commitment from senior executives to openly support gender diversity. But no amount of gender diversity policy promotion will, in isolation, overcome gender or affinity bias.
Certainly there are still questions to answer, but we hope our findings are a catalyst that sparks continued and important dialogue about gender diversity in Australia.”
For more, download the Hays/Insync report below.
We want to share with you some step changes at Insync, which include a CEO transition.
Register to participate in Insync's national study assessing the healthcare's response to delivering telehealth practices and gain valuable patient feedback.
As the industry is tasked to recalibrate its patient engagement strategy for maximum agility & optimum sustenance, Insync is proud to be a strategic partner
We use cookies to enhance your experience. Further use is considered consent. You can read more about cookies in our Privacy Policy.
You’ll always get a real person when you contact Insync.
Let's get started